A Comparison of Different Tunings and Temperaments
The Pythagorean and Just Intonation systems are derived from the ratios and or mathematical formulas in relation to a fundamental tone. When the diatonic scales are generated for the above systems the intervals are not uniform throughout. For example if we’re in the Key of C the major second would be a D with a 9/8 ratio and the major sixth from Just Intonation would have the ratio of 5/3. If we then wanted to build a major triad for the D we would multiply 9/8 X 3/2 and get the ratio of 27/16 which would be a different note then the 5/3 sixth from the C generated from the C’s overtone series. The above truth makes harmonizing on an instrument such as the piano or guitar very difficult.
First let’s compare ratios of the different tuning systems below:
|
C Scale |
Interval |
ET Ratio |
Pythagorean Ratio |
JI ratio |
|
C |
Fundamental |
1/1 |
1/1 |
1/1 |
|
C# |
m2 |
7893/7450 |
256/243 |
16/15 |
|
D |
M2 |
5252/4679 |
9/8 |
9/8 |
|
D# |
m3 |
10754/9043 |
32/27 |
6/5 |
|
E |
M3 |
6064/4813 |
81/64 |
5/4 |
|
F |
P4 |
6793/5089 |
4/3 |
4/3 |
|
F# |
A4 |
11482/8119 |
729/512 |
45/32 |
|
G |
P5 |
10178/6793 |
3/2 |
3/2 |
|
G# |
m6 |
4813/3032 |
128/81 |
8/5 |
|
A |
M6 |
9043/5377 |
27/16 |
5/3 |
|
A# |
m7 |
17189/9647 |
16/9 |
9/5 |
|
B |
M7 |
17843/9452 |
243/128 |
15/8 |
|
C |
Octave |
2/1 |
2/1 |
2/1 |
Let’s look at a chart measured in cents of the differences in interval size for the three systems. As you can see there is a great discrepancy in the size of a number of the intervals.
|
C Scale |
Interval |
Equal Temperament |
Pythagorean |
Just Intonation |
|
C |
Fundamental |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
C# |
m2 |
100 |
114 |
111.7 |
|
D |
M2 |
200 |
204 |
203.9 |
|
D# |
m3 |
300 |
294 |
315.6 |
|
E |
M3 |
400 |
408 |
386.3 |
|
F |
P4 |
500 |
498 |
498 |
|
F# |
A4 |
600 |
612 |
590.2 |
|
G |
P5 |
700 |
702 |
702 |
|
G# |
m6 |
800 |
816 |
813.7 |
|
A |
M6 |
900 |
906 |
884.4 |
|
A# |
m7 |
1000 |
996 |
1017.6 |
|
B |
M7 |
1100 |
1110 |
1088.3 |
|
C |
Octave |
1200 |
1200 |
1200 |
Note the discrepancies in Cent values.